Case
File Name: In Re Black Hills Bentonite Permit to Mine No. 248C
EQC Docket Number: 17-1601
Date Opened: 9/20/2017
AG Attorney: James Kaste
Prevailing Party: Petitioner
Date of Disposition: 5/24/2018
Date File Closed: 5/24/2018
Archive Date:
Archive Box:
City: Casper
County: Natrona
DEQ File Number: Permit No 248C
Division: Council Actions
Case type: Permit Holders Appeal
Hearing Examiner: Lally
Summary: Black Hills Bentonite petitioned for an Order in Lieu of Consent pursuant to 35-11-406(b)(xii)
Hearing
TitleWhenLocation
Scheduling Conference12/7/2017 1:30:00 PMEQC offices 122 West 25th St. 1st Floor West Herschler Building, Cheyenne WY 82009

Documents

 ViewDateTitleFiled ByDocument TypeStatus
9/20/2017Petition for Order in Lieu of ConsentJim RubyPleadingAccepted
9/20/2017Exhibit 1 Black Hills BentoniteJim RubyPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/20/2017Exhibit 2 Black Hills BentoniteJim RubyPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/20/2017Exhibit 3 Black Hills BentoniteJim RubyPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/20/2017Exhibit 4 Black Hills BentoniteJim RubyPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/20/2017Exhibit 5 Black Hills BentoniteJim RubyPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/20/2017Dave Ditto agreed to receive service by emailDave DittoEmail Service AgreementAccepted
9/22/2017Exhibit 1 with oversized PlatJim RubyPleading ExhibitAccepted
10/17/2017Jim Crossingham Return ReceiptDave DittoLettersAccepted
10/31/2017Order for Scheduling ConferenceJim RubyOrderAccepted
11/1/2017Corrected Certificate of Service(Removed)Jim RubyOrderRemoved
11/1/2017Corrected Certificate of ServiceJim RubyOrderAccepted
11/17/2017Scott Klosterman agreed to receive service by emailScott KlostermanEmail Service AgreementAccepted
11/20/2017Stipulated Motion to Reschedule Hearing Date and Set Second Pre-Hearing ConferenceScott KlostermanPleadingAccepted
11/20/2017Order Granting Stipulated Motion to Reschedule Hearing Date and Set Second Pre-Hearing ConferenceScott KlostermanPleadingAccepted
11/27/2017Order of Continuance for final hearing(Removed)Jim RubyOrderRemoved
11/27/2017Order for Continuance of Final HearingJim RubyOrderAccepted
11/29/2017Response In Opposition to Petition to the EQC For Order In Lieu of Landowner ConsentScott KlostermanPleadingAccepted
11/29/2017Exhibit "A" to Response in OppositionScott KlostermanPleading ExhibitAccepted
11/29/2017Exhibit "B" to Response in OppositionScott KlostermanPleading ExhibitAccepted
11/29/2017Exhibit "C" to Response in OppositionScott KlostermanPleading ExhibitAccepted
11/29/2017Exhibit "D" to Response in OppositionScott KlostermanPleading ExhibitAccepted
11/29/2017Exhibit "E" to Response in OppositionScott KlostermanPleading ExhibitAccepted
11/29/2017Exhibit "F" to Response in OppositionScott KlostermanPleading ExhibitAccepted
11/29/2017Exhibit "G" to Response in OppositionScott KlostermanPleading ExhibitAccepted
12/7/2017Scheduling Order through stipulationJim RubyOrderAccepted
1/15/2018Petitioner's Expert Witness Designation(Removed)Dave DittoPleadingRemoved
1/16/2018 Petitioner's Expert Witness DesignationJoe GirardinPleadingAccepted
1/16/2018Petitioner's Expert Witness Designation(Removed)Dave DittoPleadingRemoved
1/16/2018Petitioner's Expert Witness Designation(Removed)Dave DittoPleadingRemoved
2/9/2018Respondents' Motion to Continue HearingScott KlostermanPleadingAccepted
2/9/2018Exhibit A to Respondents' Motion to Continue HearingScott KlostermanPleading ExhibitAccepted
2/9/2018Proposed Order Granting Respondents' Motion to Continue HearingScott KlostermanPleadingAccepted
2/10/2018Respondents' Prehearing Disclosure StatementScott KlostermanPleadingAccepted
2/12/2018Petitioner's Objection to ContinuanceDave DittoPleadingAccepted
2/12/2018Petitioner's Proposed Order on Respondent's Motion to Continue HearingDave DittoPleadingAccepted
2/12/2018Petitioners Prehearing Disclosure StatementDave DittoPleadingAccepted
2/12/2018Petitioniers Notice of Additional ExhibitsDave DittoPleadingAccepted
2/13/2018Order denying Motion to ContinueJim RubyOrderAccepted
2/13/2018Amended Order Denying Motion to ContinueJim RubyOrderAccepted
2/13/2018Amended Order Denying Motion to Continue(Removed)Jim RubyOrderRemoved
2/16/2018Petitioner's Motion to Strike Hearing WitnessesDave DittoPleadingAccepted
2/16/2018Proposed Order on Motion to Strike WitnessesDave DittoPleadingAccepted
2/18/2018Respondents' Notice of Additional ExhibitScott KlostermanPleadingAccepted
2/19/2018Petitioner's Objection to Immaterial, irrelevant and Inappropriate EvidenceDave DittoPleadingAccepted
2/19/2018Order on Petitioner's Objection to Irrelevant, Immaterial and Inappropriate EvidenceDave DittoPleadingAccepted
3/16/2018Final Hearing TranscriptJim RubyTranscriptAccepted
5/24/2018Findings of Fact Conclusions of Law and OrderJim RubyOrderAccepted
6/23/2020James Kaste agreed to receive service by emailJames KasteEmail Service AgreementAccepted

Exhibits

 ViewDateTitleFiled ByDocument TypeStatus
2/10/2018TTT01Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT02Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT03Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT04Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT05Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT06Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT07Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT08Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT09Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT10Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT11Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT12Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT13Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT14Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/10/2018TTT15Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/10/2018TTT16Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/10/2018TTT17Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/10/2018TTT18Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG01Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG02Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG03Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG04Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG05Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG06Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG07Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG08(Removed)Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG09(Removed)Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG10Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG11Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG12Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG13Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG14Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG15Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG16(Removed)Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG17Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG18Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG19Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG20Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG21Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG22Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG23Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG24Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG25Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG26Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG27Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG28Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG29Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG30Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG31Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG32Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG33Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG34Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG35Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG36Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/12/2018ALG37Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG38Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG39Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG40Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG41Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/12/2018ALG42Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/15/2018ALG08Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/15/2018ALG09Dave DittoFinal ExhibitDisabled
2/15/2018ALG16Dave DittoFinal ExhibitAccepted
2/18/2018TTT19Scott KlostermanFinal ExhibitAccepted

Visits = 1821