Case
File Name: Dry Fork Station Air Permit CT-4631
EQC Docket Number: 07-2801
Date Opened: 11/1/2007
AG Attorney: Vehr
Prevailing Party: Respondent
Date of Disposition: 12/2/2008
Date File Closed: 12/12/2008
Archive Date: 7/26/2018
Archive Box:
City: Gillette
County: Campbell
DEQ File Number: CT-4631
Division: Air Quality
Case type: Citizen objection to a mine permit or decision of the Director
Hearing Examiner: Searle
Summary: The Case file of this matter is also in Box 166. Pursuant to the DEQ's General Rules of Practice and Procedure, Chapter 1, Sections 3 and 16, Sierra Club, Powder River Basin Resource Council, and Wyoming Outdoor Council protest the Director's approval of Basin Electric Power Cooperative's Air Permit CT-4631 for the Dry Fork Station and request a hearing before the Council.
Hearing
TitleWhenLocation
Final Hearing11/17/2008 12:00:00 AM 

Documents

 ViewDateTitleFiled ByDocument TypeStatus
11/1/2007Protest and Petition for HearingCooleyPleadingAccepted
Archived 11/2/2007Entry of AppearanceDolan  
Archived 11/2/2007Entry of AppearanceVehr  
Archived 11/2/2007Entry of AppearanceJerde  
Archived 11/16/2007Party Letter.11-16-07Girardin  
Archived 11/19/2007Basin Electric's Motion for Extension of Time to Submit Proposed Hearing ScheduleRuppert  
Archived 11/21/2007Order Granting Basin Electric's Motion for Extention of TimeSearle  
12/5/2007Scheduling OrderSearleOrderAccepted
12/5/2007Response OrderSearleOrderAccepted
Archived 12/21/2007Permittor's and Permittee's Joint Proposed Scheduling OrderVehr, Day  
Archived 12/21/2007Protestant's Individual Proposed Scheduling OrderAngell  
12/21/2007DEQ's ResponseVehrPleadingAccepted
12/21/2007Basin Electric Power Cooperative's Response and Affirmative Defenses to the Protest and Petition for HearingRuppertPleadingAccepted
1/11/2008Scheduling Conference OrderSearleOrderAccepted
Archived 1/28/2008Stipulated Motion for Extension of Preliminary or Procedural Motions and Related Deadlines and Motion for ContinuanceRuppert,Angell,Vehr  
Archived 1/28/2008Draft Order Extending Preliminary or Procedural Motions and Related Deadlines and Continuing Hearing   
Archived 1/30/2008Order Extending Preliminary or Procedural Motions and Related Deadlines and Continuing HearingSearle  
2/1/2008DEQ's Motion for Protective OrderVehrPleadingAccepted
Archived 2/1/2008Proposed Order on Respondent DEQ's Motion for Protective OrderVehr  
2/4/2008Motion for Entry of Protective OrdersRuppertPleadingAccepted
Archived 2/4/2008Motion for Admission of Robin Cooley Pro Hac ViceAngell  
Archived 2/4/2008Motion for Admission of Andrea Zaccardi Pro Hac ViceAngell  
2/7/2008DEQ's Motion to DismissVehrPleadingAccepted
2/7/2008DEQ's Memorandum in Support of Motion to DismissVehrMemosAccepted
Archived 2/7/2008DEQ's Proposed Order for Motion to Dismiss   
2/8/2008Basin Electric Power Cooperative Inc's Motion to Dismiss AppealRuppertPleadingAccepted
Archived 2/8/2008Basin Electric's Order Dismissing AppealRuppert  
2/8/2008Motion to Suspend Air Permit CT-4631 Pending Resolution of Protestants' AppealAngellPleadingAccepted
2/8/2008Index of Exhibits to Motion to Suspend Air Permit CT-4631 Pending Resolution of Protestants' AppealAngellPleadingAccepted
2/8/2008Exhibit 1.Earth JusticeAngellPleading ExhibitAccepted
2/8/2008Exhibit 2.Earth JusticeAngellPleading ExhibitAccepted
2/8/2008Exhibit 3.Earth JusticeAngellPleading ExhibitAccepted
2/8/2008Exhibit 4-10.Earth JusticeAngellPleading ExhibitAccepted
2/8/2008Exhibit 11.Earth JusticeAngellPleading ExhibitAccepted
Archived 2/8/2008Exhibit 12.Earth JusticeAngellPleading ExhibitAccepted
Archived 2/8/2008Proposed Order Granting Motion to Suspend Air Permit CT-4631 Pending Resolution of Protestants' AppealAngell  
2/22/2008Stipulated Motion to Stay Discovery on Global Warming Issues Pending Resolution of the Department of Environmental Quality's Motion to Dismiss and WitVehrPleadingAccepted
Archived 2/22/2008Proposed Order on Motion to Stay Discovery   
Archived 2/25/2008Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Protestant's Response to Basin Electric Power Cooperative's Motion for Entry of Protective OrdersAngell  
Archived 2/25/2008Proposed Order on Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Protestant's Response to Basin Electric Power Cooperative's Motion for Entry of Protective Orde   
Archived 2/29/2008Order Granting Motion for Admission of Robin Cooley Pro Hac ViceSearle  
Archived 2/29/2008Order Granting Motion for Admission of Andrea Zaccardi Pro Hac ViceSearle  
2/29/2008Order on Stipulated Motion to Stay Discovery on Global Warming IssuesSearleOrderAccepted
2/29/2008Order on Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Protestants' Response to Basin Electric Powder Cooperative's Motion for Entry of Protective OrdersSearleOrderAccepted
3/7/2008Notice of Settlement Regarding Respondent's Motion for Entry of Protective OrdersCooleyPleadingAccepted
3/12/2008Respondent DEQ's Response Opposing Protestants' Motion to Suspend Air Permit CT-4631 Pending Resolution of Protestants' AppealVehrPleadingAccepted
3/12/2008Basin Electric's Memorandum in Support of the Department's Motion to DismissDayMemosAccepted
3/12/2008Basin Electric's Opposition to Protestant's Motion to Suspend PermitDayPleadingAccepted
3/12/2008Protestants' Exhibits 1-7.DEQ's MotionCooleyPleading ExhibitAccepted
3/12/2008Protestants' Exhibits 1-5 to Basin Electric's MotionCooleyPleading ExhibitAccepted
3/12/2008Protestants' Exhibits 8-12 to DEQ's Motion(Removed)(Removed)Cooley Removed
3/12/2008Protestants' Exhibits 13-18 to DEQ's MotionCooleyPleading ExhibitAccepted
Archived 3/12/2008Protestants' Response to DEQ's Motion to DismissCooley  
3/12/2008Protestants' Response to Basin Electric's Motion to DismissCooleyPleadingAccepted
3/20/2008Motion for Stipulated Protective Order and Confidentiality AgreementVehr, Ruppert, CooleyPleadingAccepted
Archived 3/20/2008Proposed Stipulated Protective Order and Confidentiality AgreementVehr, Ruppert, Cooley  
3/25/2008Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Expert Designation and Report DeadlinesCooleyPleadingAccepted
Archived 3/25/2008Proposed Order on Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Expert Designation and Report DeadlinesCooley  
4/3/2008Respondent DEQ's Reply in Support of It's Motion to DismissVehrPleadingAccepted
4/3/2008Basin Electric's Reply in Support of It's Motion to DismissDayPleading AffidavitAccepted
Archived 4/3/2008Entry of Appearance.ZarsZars  
4/3/2008DEQ's Attachment.2VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
4/3/2008DEQ's Attachment.3VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
4/3/2008DEQ's Attachment.4VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
Archived 4/3/2008Exhibit 1.RMCO Report   
4/3/2008Protestant's Response to Basin Electric's Memo. In Support of the Dept.'s Motion to Dismiss PleadingAccepted
4/3/2008Protestant's Exhibit Index PleadingAccepted
4/3/2008Protestant's Exhibit 2 Pleading ExhibitAccepted
4/3/2008Protestant's Exhibit 3 Pleading AffidavitAccepted
4/3/2008Protestant's Reply in Further Support of their Motion to Suspend Air Permit CT-4631 Pending Resolution of Appeal PleadingAccepted
4/4/2008Order Changing the Date for Motion HearingsSearleOrderAccepted
4/11/2008Order on Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Expert Designation and Report DeadlinesSearleOrderAccepted
4/23/2008Stipulated Protective Order and Confidentiality AgreementSearlePleadingAccepted
4/24/2008Order Changing the Time for Motion HearingsSearleOrderAccepted
4/24/2008Notice of Additional Authoriy.DEQ Motion to DismissEarthjusticePleadingAccepted
4/24/2008Exhibit 1.Earthjustice.Federal RegisterEarthjusticePleading ExhibitAccepted
4/24/2008Exhibit 2.Earthjustice.Letter to JohnsonEarthjusticePleading ExhibitAccepted
4/24/2008Notice of Additional Authority.Basin's Motion to DismissEarthjusticePleadingAccepted
4/24/2008Exhibit 1.Earthjustice.Order on Intervention.Basin's Motion to DismissEarthjusticePleadingAccepted
Archived 4/28/2008Motion to Withdraw.DolanDolan  
Archived 5/2/2008Order Granting Motion to Withdraw.DolanSearle  
Archived 5/12/2008Order Vacating Scheduling/Argument ConferenceSearle  
Archived 6/18/2008Entry of AppearanceEsch  
Archived 7/11/2008Stipulated Motion for Extension of Deposition and Dispositive Motions DeadlinesRuppert,Vehr,Zaccardi  
Archived 7/14/2008Order Granting Stipulated Motion for Extension of Deposition and Dispositive Motions DeadlinesSearle  
Archived 8/6/2008Basin Electric's Notice of Depositions Duces Tecum of Mike Fowler, Rinajit Sahu and Khanh TranRuppert  
Archived 8/11/2008Order changing the Location for the dispositive Motion HearingSearle  
Archived 8/21/2008Order Denying Basin Electric Power Cooperative Inc.'s Motion to Dismiss AppealBoal  
Archived 8/21/2008Order Denying Protestant's Motion to Suspend Air Permit CT-4631 Pending Resolution of Protestants' AppealBoal  
Archived 8/21/2008Order Granting Respondent Department of Environmental Quality's Motion to DismissBoal  
Archived 8/25/2008Order on Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Dispositive Motion Briefing DeadlineSearle  
Archived 8/25/2008Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Dispositive Motion Briefing DeadlineAngell,Day,Vehr  
Archived 8/25/2008Proposed Order on Stipulated Motion for Continuance of Dispositive Motion Briefing Deadline   
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 41Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 42Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 43Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 44Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 45Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Basin Electric's Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary Judgement on Protestants' Claims Regarding Redefinition of the Source, PM2.5 and Alleged Ruppert  
Archived 9/2/2008Basin Electric's Motion for Summary Judgement on Protestants' Claims Regarding Redefinition of the Source, PM2.5 and Alleged Class I Increment ViolatiRuppert  
Archived 9/2/2008Respondent DEQ's Memorandum in Support of Motion for Partial Summary JudgmentVehr  
Archived 9/2/2008Respondent DEQ's Motion for Partial Summary JudgmentVehr  
Archived 9/2/2008Annex to the WY DEQ's Motion for Partial Summary JudgmentVehr  
Archived 9/2/2008Proposed Order on Respondent DEQ's Motion for Partial Summary JudgmentVehr  
Archived 9/2/2008Protestants' Motion for Summary JudgmentCooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 5Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 4Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 1Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 3Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 6Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 2Cooley  
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-AVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-BVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-CVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-DVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-EVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-FVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-GVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-HVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-IVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-JVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-KVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
Archived 9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-LVehr  
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-MVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-NVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-OVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-PVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-QVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-RVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-SVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-TVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-UVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-VVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-WVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 1-XVehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 2VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 3VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 4VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 5VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 6VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 7VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 8VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 9VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008DEQ.Exhibit 10VehrPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 10-2RuppertPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 10-3RuppertPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 10-4RuppertPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 10-1RuppertPleading ExhibitAccepted
9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 10RuppertPleading ExhibitAccepted
Archived 9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 1-3Ruppert  
Archived 9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 4Ruppert  
Archived 9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 5-9Ruppert  
Archived 9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 11-14Ruppert  
Archived 9/2/2008Basin Electric.Exhibit 15-18Ruppert  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 7Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 8Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 9Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 10Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 11Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 12Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 13Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 14Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 15Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 16Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 17Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 18Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 19Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 20Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 21Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 22Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 23Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 24Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 25Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 26Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 27Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 28Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 29Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 30Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 31Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 32Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 33Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 34Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 35Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 36Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 37Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 38Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 39Cooley  
Archived 9/2/2008Earthjustice.Exhibit 40Cooley  
Archived 9/12/2008Response to Protestants' Statement of Undisputed FactsRuppert  
Archived 9/12/2008Basin Electric's Memorandum in Opposition to Protestants' Motion for Summary JudgmentDay  
Archived 9/12/2008Respondent DEQ's Brief in Opposition to Protestants' Motion for Summary JudgmentJerde  
Archived 9/12/2008Response to the Annex to the DEQ's Motion for Partial Summary JudgmentZaccardi  
Archived 9/12/2008Response to Basin Electric's Annex of Undisputed FactsZaccardi  
Archived 9/12/2008Protestant's Response to DEQ's and Basin's Motions for Summary JudgmentCooley  
Archived 9/12/2008Earthjustice Dispositive Response.Exh.46Cooley  
Archived 9/12/2008Earthjustice Dispositive Response.Exh.47Cooley  
Archived 9/12/2008Earthjustice Dispositive Response.Exh.48Cooley  
Archived 9/12/2008Earthjustice.Dispositive Response.Exh.49Cooley  
Archived 9/12/2008Earthjustice.Dispositive Response.Exh.50Cooley  
Archived 9/12/2008Earthjustice.Dispositive Response.Exh.51Cooley  
Archived 9/12/2008Earthjustice.Dispositive.Response.Exh.52Cooley  
Archived 9/12/2008DEQ's Dispositive Response.63-Exh.11Jerde  
Archived 9/12/2008DEQ's Dispositive Response.63-Exh.12Jerde  
Archived 9/12/2008DEQ's Dispositive Response.63-Exh.13Jerde  
Archived 9/12/2008DEQ's Dispositive Response.63-Exh.14Jerde  
Archived 9/12/2008DEQ's Dispositive Response.63-Exh.15Jerde  
Archived 9/12/2008DEQ's Dispositive Response.63-Exh.16Jerde  
Archived 9/19/2008Respondent DEQ's Reply to Protestants' Response to DEQ's and Basin's Motion for Summary JudgmentVehr  
Archived 9/19/2008Basin Electric's Reply in Support of It's Motion for Summary JudgmentDay  
Archived 9/19/2008Proposed Order on protestant's Motion to Strike   
Archived 9/19/2008Protestant's Motion to Strike the Affidavit of Kenneth J. Snell as to PM2.5 and MercuryZaccardi  
Archived 9/19/2008Protestant's Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment with ExhibitsCooley-Zars  
Archived 9/26/2008Basin Electric Power Cooperative's Response to Protestants' Motion to Strike the Affidavit of Kenneth J. Snell as to PM 2.5 and MercuryRuppert  
Archived 9/29/2008Earthjustice Handout.9-29-08Cooley  
Archived 9/29/2008Basin Electric Presentation.9-29-08Day  
Archived 9/29/2008DEQ Presentation.9-29-08Vehr  
Archived 9/29/2008Earthjustice Presentation.9-29-08Cooley  
Archived 9/29/2008DEQ Mercury Bact Presentation.9-29-08Vehr  
Archived 9/29/2008DEQ PM 2.5 Analysis Presentation.9-29-08Vehr  
Archived 9/29/2008DEQ SO 2 Increment Analysis Presentation.9-29-08Vehr  
Archived 10/10/2008Joint Motion to Extend Deadline for Submitting Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawVehr,Ruppert  
Archived 10/10/2008Proposed Order on Joint Motion to Extend Deadline for Submitting Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawVehr, Ruppert  
Archived 10/14/2008Order for the Pre-hearing ConferenceSearle  
Archived 10/16/2008Joint Stipulation for Withdrawal of Protestants' Claims IV, V, and VICooley, Ruppert, Vehr  
Archived 10/16/2008Proposed Order Approving Joint Stipulation for Withdrawal of Protestants' Claims IV, V, and VICooley, Ruppert, Vehr  
Archived 10/17/2008Proposed Order Denying Protestants' Motion to Strike Affidavit of Kenneth J. Snell as to PM2.5 and MercuryRuppert  
Archived 10/17/2008Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claim VIII)Ruppert, Vehr  
Archived 10/17/2008Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claim VII)Ruppert, Vehr  
Archived 10/17/2008Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claims II and III)Ruppert, Vehr  
Archived 10/23/2008Protestants' Opposition to Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claim VIII - So2 Increment)Cooley  
Archived 10/23/2008Opposition to Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claim VII - PM2.5)Cooley  
Archived 10/23/2008Opposition to Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claims II and III - IGCC and Supercritical Technologies)Cooley  
Archived 10/29/2008Reply to Protestants' Opposition to the Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawVehr  
Archived 10/29/2008Affidavit of Chad Schlichtemeier to Correct Statements Made Before the WY EQC in the Hearings on the Motions for Partial Summary JudgmentVehr  
Archived 10/29/2008Affidavit of Ken Rairigh to Correct Statements Made Before the WY EQC in the Hearings on the Motions for Partial Summary JudgementVehr  
Archived 10/29/2008Attachment to Reply to Protestants' OppositionVehr  
Archived 10/29/2008Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claims II and III - IGCC and Supercritical Tech.)Vehr  
Archived 10/29/2008Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claim VII - PM2.5)Vehr  
Archived 10/29/2008Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Claim VIII - SO2 Increment)Vehr  
Archived 11/19/2008Notice of Supplemental Authority and Motion to Reconsider Order Granting Respondent Department of Environmental Quality's Motion to DismissCooley  
Archived 11/25/2008Joint Stipulation and Motion to Amend "Order Granting Basin Electric Cooperative's and Department of Environmental Quality's Motions for Summary JudgmRuppert  
Archived 11/25/2008Order Nunc Pro Tunc Amending "Order Granting Basin Electric Copperative's and Department of Environmental Quality's Motions for Summary Judgement RegaRuppert  
Archived 11/26/2008Basin Response to Motion to ReconsiderRuppert  
Archived 11/26/2008DEQ Response to Motion to ReconsiderVehr  
Archived 12/8/2008Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration Final.pdfBoal  
Archived 12/8/2008Order Nunc Pro Tunc Amending Order Granting Basin Electric Cooperative's and Department of Environmental Quality's Motions for Summary Judgement RegarBoal  
Archived 12/8/2008Order Granting Basin Electric Cooperative's and Department of Environmental Quality's Motions for Summary Judgment Regarding Protestants' Claim VIII.pBoal  
Archived 12/8/2008Order Granting Basin Electric Cooperative's and Department of Environmental Quality's Motions for Summary Judgment Regarding Protestants' Claim VII.pdBoal  
Archived 12/8/2008Order Granting Basin Electric Cooperative's and Department of Environmental Quality's Motions for Summary Judgment Regarding Protestant's Claims II anBoal  
Archived 12/8/2008Order Denying Protestant's Motion to Strike Affidavit of Kenneth J. Snell as to PM2.5 and Mercury.pdfBoal  
Archived 12/8/2008Order Denying Protestants' Motion for Summary Judgment Regarding Claim V.pdfBoal  
Archived 12/12/2008Order Approving Joint Stipulation for Withdrawal of Protestants' Claims IV, V, and VIBoal  
7/31/2018Earth Justice Exhibit 8-12 on Motion to Dismiss by DEQJim RubyPleading ExhibitAccepted

Visits = 9246