04-3801 4W Ranch Objection

Case

File Name: 4W Ranch Objection

EQC Docket Number: 04-3801

Date Opened: 6/3/2004

AG Attorney: Barrash

Prevailing Party: Respondent

Date of Disposition: 3/5/2007

Date File Closed: 3/5/2007

Archive Date: 2/11/2016

Archive Box:

City: Newcastle

County: Weston

DEQ File Number: WY0051233

Division: Water Quality

Case type: Citizen objection to a mine permit or decision of the Director

Hearing Examiner: Brady

Summary: Objection from a downstream landowner to these permits because he believes the C.M. discharges to the Cheyenne drainage will damage his land and impair the established water rights.

Hearing

Title

When

Location

Final Hearing

9/26/2006 12:00:00 AM

Documents

View	Date	Title	Filed By	Document Type	Status
View	6/3/2004	Request for Hearing	Harshbarger	Pleading	Accepted
Archived	8/18/2004	Entry of Appearance	Harris
Archived	8/19/2004	Amend Cert of Service of Entry of Appearance	Harris
Archived	6/15/2005	Letter, Girardin to parties - ca`se update
Archived	6/29/2005	Letter, Harshbarger to Girardin - request for hear
Archived	7/13/2005	Case Update	Barrash
Archived	9/13/2005	Letter from Major Harshbarger	Harshbarger
Archived	10/5/2005	Order for Response Request	Brady
Archived	1/10/2006	Order - Case Update
View	1/25/2006	DEQ's Response to Appeal by 4W Ranch	Barrash	Pleading	Accepted
Archived	1/31/2006	Call from Lynda Zeringue requesting extension for 1 day for response for update.
Archived	4/21/2006	Letter to Parties requesting Permit No. information	Girardin
Archived	5/2/2006	Letter from Maj. Robert L. Harshbarger	Harshbarger
Archived	5/19/2006	Entry of Appearance	Reimer
Archived	5/23/2006	Order for Scheduling Conference Call
Archived	6/9/2006	Phone Call to John Sundahl	McGee
Archived	6/14/2006	Message from John Sundahl's office	McGee
Archived	6/15/2006	Phone Call from John Sundahl's office	McGee
Archived	6/15/2006	Entry of Appearance	Sundahl
Archived	6/27/2006	Notice of Hearing and Order
Archived	6/28/2006	Amended Notice of Hearing and Order
Archived	7/28/2006	Bill Barrett Corporation Response to 4W Ranch Appeal	Reimer
Archived	7/31/2006	Designation of Expert Witnesses by Merit Energy Company	Sundahl
Archived	8/15/2006	Pre-hearing Info.Harshbarger Letter	Harshbarger
Archived	8/17/2006	DEQ's Prehearing Memorandum	Barrash
Archived	8/17/2006	Motion to Dismiss Petitioners' Appeal Against Merit Energy Company's NPDES Permit No. 51373	Sundahl
Archived	8/18/2006	Bill Barrett Corporation Motion for Summary Judgment	Reimer
Archived	8/18/2006	Prehearing Memorandum of Bill Barrett Corporation with Exhibits	Reimer
Archived	8/21/2006	Harshbarger Prehearing Memorandum	Harshbarger
Archived	8/21/2006	Respondent Merit Energy Company's Prehearing Memorandum	Sundahl
Archived	9/6/2006	4W Ranch Response to the Bill Barrett Corporation Motion for Summary Judgment	Harshbarger
Archived	9/6/2006	4W Ranch Response to the Motion to Dismiss Petitioner's Appeal Against Merit Energy Company's NPDES Permit	Harshbarger
Archived	9/7/2006	Stipulation on Exhibits	Sundahl
Archived	9/7/2006	Order Granting Respondent Merit Energy Company's Motion to Dismiss	Sundahl
Archived	9/12/2006	Pre-hearing Conference Order
Archived	9/13/2006	Amended Prehearing Conference Order
Archived	9/14/2006	Respondent Merit Energy Company's Motion for Order or, In the Alternative, For Expedited Hearing On It's Motion to Dismiss	Sundahl
Archived	9/14/2006	Draft Order Setting Hearing on Motion to Dismiss	Sundahl
Archived	9/21/2006	Stipulated Withdrawal of Petitioner's Appeal of Merit Energy Company's NPDES Permit No. 51373	Sundahl
Archived	9/22/2006	Notice of Filing Original Signatures	Sundahl
Archived	9/25/2006	Order Withdrawing Petitioners' Appeal of Merit Energy Company's NPDES Permit No. 51373	Sundahl
Archived	10/10/2006	Bill Barrett Corporation Motion for Extension of Time	Reimer
Archived	10/12/2006	Order for Extension of Time
Archived	10/16/2006	Order Granting Bill Barrett Corporation's Motion for Extension of Time
Archived	10/26/2006	Harshbarger.Letter
Archived	10/27/2006	Proposed Findings of Fact anc Conclusions of Law (Big Porcupine Permit No. WY0051233)	Reimer
Archived	11/3/2006	Bill Barrett Corporation's Motion for Remand	Ruppert
Archived	11/3/2006	Proposed Order Granting Bill Barrett Corporation's Motion For Remand	Ruppert
Archived	11/27/2006	DEQ's Response to Bill Barrett Corporation's Motion for Remand	Barrash
Archived	12/5/2006	DEQ's Comments on Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for Permit No. WY0051217 (Palm Tree Unit)	Barrash
Archived	12/6/2006	Bill Barrett Corporation's Objections to Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for Permit No. WY0051217 (Palm Tree Unit)	Reimer
Archived	12/6/2006	Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for Permit No. WY0051217 (Palm Tree Unit)	Reimer
View	3/5/2007	Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for Permit No. WY0051217 (Palm Tree Unit) and Order to Remand	Brady	Order	Accepted
View	3/5/2007	Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order for Permit No. WY0051233 (Big Porcupine)	Brady	Order	Accepted

View

View

6/3/2004

Request for Hearing

Harshbarger

Pleading

Accepted

Archived

8/18/2004

Entry of Appearance

Harris

Archived

8/19/2004

Amend Cert of Service of Entry of Appearance

Harris

Archived

6/15/2005

Letter, Girardin to parties - ca`se update

Archived

6/29/2005

Letter, Harshbarger to Girardin - request for hear

Archived

7/13/2005

Case Update

Barrash

Archived

9/13/2005

Letter from Major Harshbarger

Harshbarger

Archived

10/5/2005

Order for Response Request

Brady

Archived

1/10/2006

Order - Case Update

View

1/25/2006

DEQ's Response to Appeal by 4W Ranch

Barrash

Pleading

Accepted

Archived

1/31/2006

Call from Lynda Zeringue requesting extension for 1 day for response for update.

Archived

4/21/2006

Letter to Parties requesting Permit No. information

Girardin

Archived

5/2/2006

Letter from Maj. Robert L. Harshbarger

Harshbarger

Archived

5/19/2006

Entry of Appearance

Reimer

Archived

5/23/2006

Order for Scheduling Conference Call

Archived

6/9/2006

Phone Call to John Sundahl

McGee

Archived

6/14/2006

Message from John Sundahl's office

McGee

Archived

6/15/2006

Phone Call from John Sundahl's office

McGee

Archived

6/15/2006

Entry of Appearance

Sundahl

Archived

6/27/2006

Notice of Hearing and Order

Archived

6/28/2006

Amended Notice of Hearing and Order

Archived

7/28/2006

Bill Barrett Corporation Response to 4W Ranch Appeal

Reimer

Archived

7/31/2006

Designation of Expert Witnesses by Merit Energy Company

Sundahl

Archived

8/15/2006

Pre-hearing Info.Harshbarger Letter

Harshbarger

Archived

8/17/2006

DEQ's Prehearing Memorandum

Barrash

Archived

8/17/2006

Motion to Dismiss Petitioners' Appeal Against Merit Energy Company's NPDES Permit No. 51373

Sundahl

Archived

8/18/2006

Bill Barrett Corporation Motion for Summary Judgment

Reimer

Archived

8/18/2006

Prehearing Memorandum of Bill Barrett Corporation with Exhibits

Reimer

Archived

8/21/2006

Harshbarger Prehearing Memorandum

Harshbarger

Archived

8/21/2006

Respondent Merit Energy Company's Prehearing Memorandum

Sundahl

Archived

9/6/2006

4W Ranch Response to the Bill Barrett Corporation Motion for Summary Judgment

Harshbarger

Archived

9/6/2006

4W Ranch Response to the Motion to Dismiss Petitioner's Appeal Against Merit Energy Company's NPDES Permit

Harshbarger

Archived

9/7/2006

Stipulation on Exhibits

Sundahl

Archived

9/7/2006

Order Granting Respondent Merit Energy Company's Motion to Dismiss

Sundahl

Archived

9/12/2006

Pre-hearing Conference Order

Archived

9/13/2006

Amended Prehearing Conference Order

Archived

9/14/2006

Respondent Merit Energy Company's Motion for Order or, In the Alternative, For Expedited Hearing On It's Motion to Dismiss

Sundahl

Archived

9/14/2006

Draft Order Setting Hearing on Motion to Dismiss

Sundahl

Archived

9/21/2006

Stipulated Withdrawal of Petitioner's Appeal of Merit Energy Company's NPDES Permit No. 51373

Sundahl

Archived

9/22/2006

Notice of Filing Original Signatures

Sundahl

Archived

9/25/2006

Order Withdrawing Petitioners' Appeal of Merit Energy Company's NPDES Permit No. 51373

Sundahl

Archived

10/10/2006

Bill Barrett Corporation Motion for Extension of Time

Reimer

Archived

10/12/2006

Order for Extension of Time

Archived

10/16/2006

Order Granting Bill Barrett Corporation's Motion for Extension of Time

Archived

10/26/2006

Harshbarger.Letter

Archived

10/27/2006

Proposed Findings of Fact anc Conclusions of Law (Big Porcupine Permit No. WY0051233)

Reimer

Archived

11/3/2006

Bill Barrett Corporation's Motion for Remand

Ruppert

Archived

11/3/2006

Proposed Order Granting Bill Barrett Corporation's Motion For Remand

Ruppert

Archived

11/27/2006

DEQ's Response to Bill Barrett Corporation's Motion for Remand

Barrash

Archived

12/5/2006

DEQ's Comments on Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for Permit No. WY0051217 (Palm Tree Unit)

Barrash

Archived

12/6/2006

Bill Barrett Corporation's Objections to Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for Permit No. WY0051217 (Palm Tree Unit)

Reimer

Archived

12/6/2006

Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for Permit No. WY0051217 (Palm Tree Unit)

Reimer

View

3/5/2007

Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for Permit No. WY0051217 (Palm Tree Unit) and Order to Remand

Brady

Order

Accepted

View

3/5/2007

Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order for Permit No. WY0051233 (Big Porcupine)

Brady

Order

Accepted

Visits = 9350